NY Court System Launches Panel To Study AI Risks, Rewards

This article has been saved to your Favorites!
New York's state court system has announced a new statewide advisory panel to study how the potential implementation of artificial intelligence could improve justice in the Empire State, as well as ways to avoid ethical risks posed by the new technology.

On Thursday, Chief Administrative Judge Joseph A. Zayas and First Deputy Chief Administrative Judge Norman St. George named the 39 advisory committee members who will make up the new panel, which is tasked with identifying the benefits and minimizing the risks of navigating changes associated with artificial intelligence.

"AI's potential for driving change is extensive," Judge St. George said in a statement. "As the New York state courts begin to tap its vast potential in our ongoing efforts to streamline court operations, enhance justice services and more effectively inform the public about the judiciary's important work, we must carefully assess AI's benefits and risks, with the goal to create 'human-centered' AI tools that increase the court system's efficiency and efficacy while also incorporating human creativity and empathy."

The task force will be led by Justice Angela G. Iannacci, an appellate judge who has sat on the Second Department's AI Task Force since January 2023; Stuart Levi, a Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP partner and co-chair of the Artificial Intelligence Subcommittee of the New York City Bar Association's Digital Technologies Task Force; and New York University School of Law professor Jason Schultz, director of the school's Technology and Law Clinic.

Attorneys from BigLaw firms Cravath Swaine & Moore LLP, Proskauer Rose LLP and Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP have also been named to the panel, alongside New York State Attorney General Letitia James and Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg. Other members include state Supreme Court justices, trial and appellate court judges, judicial staff, state legislators and others.

"I have every confidence in the substantial knowledge of this preeminent committee and in the astute guidance of its three uniquely qualified co-chairs — trailblazers Angela Iannacci, Stuart Levi, and Jason Schultz — to carry out this important charge," Judge Zayas said in comments provided by the courts. "I look forward to the committee's recommendations and the advances to come in the quality and delivery of justice in New York."

Among areas of focus for the new committee are assessing potential new tools for use by judges, attorneys, litigants and court staff; establishing and providing training for judicial officers, attorneys and staff; and identifying best practices to move forward on AI integration.

Members will also study the possible need to update work standards to acknowledge AI tools, identify opportunities where AI use could increase access to justice for litigants, and examine how "questions of authenticity" relating to the use of AI might be handled through guidelines, rules or legislation.

The advisory panel was announced days after the New York State Bar Association released a report containing a set of recommendations to help Empire State attorneys navigate the use of artificial intelligence.

In that report, the bar association said the state's court system should consider integrating AI guidance into its Rules of Professional Conduct. The report also recommended legislators consider addressing AI in potential legal regulations.

"While these are incredibly exciting times, with AI showing tremendous promise for transforming court operations, improving court experiences for all users, and greatly expanding access to justice, we have to move cautiously in considering the adoption of the use of AI tools," Judge Zayas said in statements provided by the courts. "The New York state courts must aspire to the effective, responsible, and impartial use of AI, taking every step possible to guard against bias and the lack of human input, and to ensure that all security and privacy concerns are protected."

A spokesperson for the New York courts did not immediately respond to an interview request Friday.
Name Committee role Job(s)
Justice Angela G. Iannacci Co-chair Associate Justice, Appellate Division, Second Department; Co-chair, Appellate Division, Second Department Task Force on AI; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Stuart Levi Co-chair Partner, Skadden; Co-chair, Artificial Intelligence Subcommittee of the New York City Bar Association's Digital Technologies Task Force
Jason Schultz Co-chair Professor, NYU Law School; Director, NYU Technology and Law Clinic
Brian Balmes Member Deputy Chief of Staff to Deputy Chief Administrative Judge for New York City Courts Deborah Kaplan
Justice Tracy Bannister Member Associate Justice, Appellate Division, Fourth Department; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Alvin Bragg Member New York County District Attorney
Justice Fernando Camacho Member Suffolk County Supreme Court Acting Justice
Justice Margaret Chan Member New York County Supreme Court Justice (Commercial Division)
Judge Zainab Chaudhry Member Court of Claims Judge; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Diana Colon Member Chief of Staff to First Deputy Chief Administrative Judge Norman St. George
Judge Kathie Davidson Member New York State Judicial Institute Dean
Judge Vito DeStefano Member Tenth Judicial District Administrative Judge (Nassau County)
Justice Craig Doran Member Ontario County Supreme Court Justice; Chair, Unified Court System Court Modernization Action Committee; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Justice Patria Frias-Colón Member Kings County Supreme Court Justice (Civil Term); Co-chair, UCS Court Modernization Action Committee
Kristen Gonzalez Member State Senator (District 59); Chair, Internet and Technology Committee
Sheng Guo Member Director, Office of Court Administration's Division of Court Modernization
Maura Grossman Member Research Professor, University of Waterloo; Principal, Maura Grossman Law, Buffalo, N.Y.; Member, American Bar Association Task Force on Law and Artificial Intelligence
Paul Gupta Member Partner, Rimon Law; Co-chair, New York State Bar Association Technology Committee, Dispute Resolution Section
Judge Denise Hartman Member Court of Claims Judge; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Jason Hill Member Senior Technical Manager, OCA Division of Technology
Justice Kenneth Holder Member Queens County Supreme Court Justice (Criminal Term); Former Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Bruce Jackson Member Associate General Counsel and Managing Director of Strategic Partnerships, Microsoft
Letitia James Member New York State Attorney General
Karen Kane Member Director of Court Research, OCA Division of Technology and Court Research
Sherry Levin Wallach Member Deputy Executive Director, Legal Aid Society of Westchester County and Former President, New York State Bar Association
Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels Member Appellate Division, First Department Associate Justice; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Karl Pflanz Member Principal Law Clerk to Chief Administrative Judge Joseph A. Zayas
Justice Stan Pritzker Member Appellate Division, Third Department Associate Justice; Member, Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Strategic Initiative Jurisdiction Team, National Courts and Sciences Institute
Scott Reents Member Of counsel, Cravath; Co-chair, UCS Court Modernization Action Committee
Judge Richard Rivera Member Statewide Coordinating Judge for Family Court Matters
David Scher Member Partner, Block O'Toole; President, New York State Trial Lawyers Association
Lauren Seiter Member Supervising Court Attorney to Deputy Chief Administrative Judge for Courts Outside New York City James P. Murphy
Judge Toko Serita Member Statewide Coordinating Judge for Problem-Solving Courts
William Silverman Member Partner, Proskauer; Co-Chair, UCS Court Modernization Action Committee
Christine Sisario Member Director, OCA Division of Technology
Michelle Smith Member Chief of Staff to Deputy Chief Administrative Judge for Justice Initiatives Edwina G. Richardson
Judge Jeffrey Sunshine Member Statewide Coordinating Judge for Matrimonial Matters
Josh Tucker Member Partner, Pillsbury
Clyde Vanel Member State Assembly Member (District 33); Chair, Subcommittee on Internet and New Technology
--Graphics by Ben Jay. Additional reporting by Matt Perez. Editing by Amy French.

Correction: An earlier version of this article included an incorrect committee name. The error has been corrected.


For a reprint of this article, please contact reprints@law360.com.

×

Law360

Law360 Law360 UK Law360 Tax Authority Law360 Employment Authority Law360 Insurance Authority Law360 Real Estate Authority Law360 Healthcare Authority Law360 Bankruptcy Authority

Rankings

NEWLeaderboard Analytics Social Impact Leaders Prestige Leaders Pulse Leaderboard Women in Law Report Law360 400 Diversity Snapshot Rising Stars Summer Associates

National Sections

Modern Lawyer Courts Daily Litigation In-House Mid-Law Legal Tech Small Law Insights

Regional Sections

California Pulse Connecticut Pulse DC Pulse Delaware Pulse Florida Pulse Georgia Pulse New Jersey Pulse New York Pulse Pennsylvania Pulse Texas Pulse

Site Menu

Subscribe Advanced Search About Contact